After trying these four scar removal products intensively for three months, I personally prefer Dermatix the best. A 28-year-old male asked: can mederma and vitamin e oil both be used on scars at the same time? If you’re experiencing a medical issue, please contact a healthcare professional or dial 911 immediately. Silicone actually reduces the production of … Vitamin E is an ingredient in most skin creams, and when applied topically, a small amount penetrates the skin surface where it has beneficial antioxidant effects, according to the Linus Pauling Institute at Oregon State University. Ask doctors free. Aa. While both products can work on hypertrophic and keloid scars, ScarAway has taken the lead as this product is a better option if you want to reduce scar height. The effectiveness of topical vitamin E in treating surgical wounds is not proven, and in some individuals it can cause contact dermatitis. A 1999 study performed at the University of Miami Department of Dermatology and Cutaneous Surgery showed that applying topical vitamin E not only did not help the appearance of scar tissue, but in some cases actually worsened the cosmetic appearance of scars 3. If your skin is marked as the result of acne or an injury, or if you are healing from a surgical incision, you may wish to use a product to help minimize scarring. A. This gel is prominent and it is highly likely that your doctor or pharmacist will recommend it to you for your skin care. 2006;32(2):193-197. doi:10.1111/j.1524-4725.2006.32045.x. I have a small (2.5inch) surgical scar and would like to make it look less visible. Mederma is a topical scar gel which is applied once a day to assist in the minimization of the appearance of any scar, whether new or old. I have a small (2.5inch) surgical scar and would like to make it look less visible. Best Scar Cream for Face - Vitamin E Oil for Skin After Surgery - Stretch Mark Remover for Men & Women - Anti Aging Lotion - Acne Scar Removal for Old Scars on Body - Scar … Conclusion: Dermatix vs Mederma vs Bio-Oil vs Remescar. Also, which product works better Mederma or Vitamin E? Thanks for your question. A 1999 study performed at the University of Miami Department of Dermatology and Cutaneous Surgery showed that applying topical vitamin E not only did not help the appearance of scar tissue, but in some cases actually worsened the cosmetic appearance of scars 3. While we do connect people with vetted, board-certified doctors, we don’t provide medical consultations, diagnosis, or advice. Ask doctors free. Communities > Dermatology > mederma vs. petroleum jelly for scars. There's a popular belief that rubbing vitamin E oil onto your acne scars can help them heal quickly, and reduce their visibility. The primary active ingredient in the product’s patented formula is a proprietary botanical extract called Cepalin. J Clin Aesthet Dermatol. It is a good product that contains an onion extract and a few … A doctor recommended to use either Scar Gel or Mederma. It is used once daily on the affected area. There is a number of conflicting sources that seems to indicate no topical or cosmetic benefits are obtained by applying onion extract to one’s scar. Adv Wound Care. Many products like our very own Selevax Scar Cream have vitamin E in them. It also deeply conditions to reduce the appearance of scars. You use the gel three to four times per day for eight weeks on a new scar, or for three to six months on an existing scar 2.  My personal favorite of all the silicone scar gels/creams is called Biocorneum+. If using the pill form, puncture the capsule with a pin and squeeze out the liquid. How to use Vitamin E oil for Scars? Procedure: Take a look at the … It concluded that: Mederma vs Vaseline. In my opinion I think scar massage in combination with silicone gel sheets are the best remedies for having imperceptible scars.... Silicone based scar gels are actually proven to help the appearance of the scars with good data. Dermatol Surg. You can apply Mederma to a wound as soon as it is healed, or in the case of surgical scars, when the sutures are removed 2. 05 December, 2018 . This breathable scar cream relies on silicone and vitamin E to help reduce scars, most especially recent scars from surgery or injury. [ Read: How to Remove Scars with Vitamin E oil] 3. Best scar … I think Mederma is a waste of money and time, and there is no proof that it actually has any lasting effect on the quality of the resultant scar. No scientific studies have proven any one of them as the clear winner. Draelos ZD, Baumann L, Fleischer AB Jr, Plaum S, Avakian EV, Hardas B. Having said that, I will be happy to throw my opinion into the mix. While cocoa butter may be helpful for some aspects of skin health, there is no evidence to support its ability to flatten and reduce the appearance of scars. You can also purchase a commercial product, Mederma, which claims to diminish scars 2. I was sensitive to both and ended up red, itchy and irritated. 2012;5(6):18-24. Scaraway’s ScarAway Scar Treatment Gel delivers better results when used in the treatment of all types of scars.. It’s unique silicone gel-based formulation using the Polysiloxanes (Silicone Gel) as the main ingredient is highly effective.. Top answers from doctors based on your search: Disclaimer. Neither trial found that Mederma improved the appearance of scars more than petroleum jelly. There is no question, research has clearly shown that the use of certain topical creams and ointments will aid in the healing process. Although we strive to deliver accurate and up-to-date information, no guarantee to that effect is made. But what should you choose, Mederma or Vitamin E? This study concluded that scars treated with Mederma were significantly softer in appearance. http://www.surgery90210.com/cosmetic-dermatology/38/scar-revision.aspx. These are the bonds which hold collagen fibers together, therefore, if you put enough Vitamin E on a well done surgical scar, it will break the bonds and make the scar … Vitamin E has long been touted as a useful treatment for scars. Vitamin E is an ingredient in most skin creams, and when applied topically, a small amount penetrates the skin surface where it has beneficial antioxidant effects, according to the Linus Pauling Institute at Oregon State University. Anecdotal reports on the other hand are promising. Vitamin E ; Mederma ; Vitamin E Effects ; Mederma Effects ; Written by Gwen Bruno . At the study's end, the vitamin-E-enriched cream had no effect on, or actually worsened, the cosmetic appearance of scars. 1-3 Vitamin E is made up of four pairs of racemic stereoisomers that are derivatives of tocol and tocotrienol and is part of a class of related compounds, the tocopherols, of which alpha-tocopherol is the most important component. Silicone scar strips were fantastic! Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery: Effect of Mederma on Hypertrophic Scarring in the Rabbit Ear Model, Dermatology.org: Topical Vitamin E Formulations: Not Always Benign, Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology: Study Shows Mederma's Effectiveness. She is a former teacher and librarian, and she holds a bachelor's degree in education from Augustana College and master's degrees in education and library science from North Park University and the University of Wisconsin. "can mederma and vitamin e oil both be used on scars at the same time?" What works the best for scars, mederma or silicone gel scar sheets? Usually, I do not like to write a review, but this product by Natco Pharmacy has impressed me a lot. Evidence from scientific studies suggests against the use of vitamin E as a scar preventive. Just a tiny little dot rubbed over scar and on neck. One brand that has garnered much unwarranted attention over the years is Mederma, a popular scar gel that contains cepalin, an onion extract. Top answers from doctors based on your search: Disclaimer. A new proprietary onion extract gel improves the appearance of new scars: a randomized, controlled, blinded-investigator study. Well, in this article I seek to examine the benefits and side effects of Mederma scar gel or cream. Neither vitamin E or Mederma worked for me. Vitamin E alone and also with other natural ingredients can be used for healing the marks of scars both acne scars and surgical scars. So, we decided it was high time we wrote a proper review for it. At Healthfully, we strive to deliver objective content that is accurate and up-to-date. Does this scar cream work when applied for scars, uneven skin tone and stretch marks? If your skin is marked as the result of acne or an injury, or if you are healing from a surgical incision, you may wish to use a product to help minimize scarring. Is anyone out there that has used any of these products and has good results. Linus Pauling Institute Research Report: All About E: Does Topical Vitamin E Improve Skin Appearance? Explore the Mederma Scar Gel before and after results in this post. Fact Checked. Merz Pharmaceuticals, makers of Mederma products, claim that using Mederma helps make scars less noticeable and promotes softer and smoother skin tissue in the area of the scar 2. We will analyze the ingredients, effectiveness, and cost of each and tell you who the winner is for scar reduction. Best, Dr. Karamanoukian Los Angeles. … mederma vs vitamin e oil for scars. Remescar Silicone Scar Stick retails for SGD30 at Guardian, Watsons, Unity, Lazada, and major pharmacies. In tummy tuck and other lift/tightening surgeries, tension is the enemy. This Mederma Advanced Scar Gel review provides everything you need to know about the product, how effective it is and if its right for you. A. The sources cited below consist of evidence from peer-reviewed journals, prominent medical organizations, academic associations, and government data. Mederma Vs. Vitamin E Oil. Answered by Dr. Richard Tholen: Sure. Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for Mederma Advanced Scar Gel - 1x Daily - Reduces The Appearance of Old & New Scars - #1 Doctor & Pharmacist Recommended Brand for Scars - 1.76oz. It has been two weeks since surgery and I think the skin is healed. Vitamin E is the term used to describe a group of tocol and tocotrienol derivatives, one of which -- alpha-tocopherol -- is a useful part of the human diet. 2019;8. doi:10.12688/f1000research.18293.1, Junker JPE, Kamel RA, Caterson EJ, Eriksson E. Clinical Impact Upon Wound Healing and Inflammation in Moist, Wet, and Dry Environments. My sister has some nail scratches on her face. A. Vitamin E is essential in helping to protect your cells and body tissues from damage and also helps keep your red blood cells healthy. These reports say that Mederma Skin Care for Scars really can reduce the appearance of scars. The active ingredients at work here are allicin, which is found in garlic and onion bulbs and helps reduce the appearance of scars; allantoin, which helps condition the skin to reduce the appearance of scars; and vitamin B5, which works as a moisturizing skin softener. Close Dermatology Community 54k Members mederma vs. petroleum jelly for scars jeric. After the surgery (and when all wounds were primarily closed in two layers), participants applied vitamin E mixed into a cream to one part of their scar twice daily for four weeks and the cream alone to another part of their scar, also twice daily for four weeks. Care for your skin with the #1 doctor and pharmacist recommended brand in the scar reduction treatments category. The Mederma web site lists some scientific reports that support their claims. Which is better for scar treatment: Mederma Advanced Scar Gel or Bio-Oil? Onion extract gel versus petrolatum emollient on new surgical scars: prospective double-blinded study. Which is disencouraged to use on scars because it does not work and may cause skin irritation and even worsen … Mederma products visibly reduce the appearance of scars and stretch marks. Shea Butter and Vitamin E oil for Scars: Shea butter is known to be powerful towards treating scars. Our team periodically reviews articles in order to ensure content quality. Chung VQ, Kelley L, Marra D, Jiang SB. A randomized, double-blinded, split-scar study showed no more improvement after the use of Mederma as the onion extract gel on scars compared to a petroleum based ointment (such as Vaseline). If you experience any symptoms, discontinue use of the product and consult your physician. Bio oil and Cocoa Butter for Scars: Bio‑Oil helps in improving the look and appearance of both new and old scars. Which one is a better one? In our office, we suggest twice daily application of Plato's Scar Serum. When using either treatment, watch for evidence of itching or swelling. Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users. Scars caused due to surgery, burns, accidents, scratches or acne or chickenpox can be treated with this oil enriched with Vitamin E. Ingredients: Cocoa Butter; Bio Oil; Preparation Time: 5 mins. If used according to the time frame recommended, it can do wonders in fading your old scars. Consuming foods that contain vitamin E can help promote the proper healing of your skin, which can decrease the size of your scar, making it less noticeable. You are doing all the right things. Thank you for your post. The "Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology" reported on a 2009 study that found among subjects who had lesions removed from their upper chests, more than three-quarters of those using Mederma reported a moderate to significant improvement is the appearance of their scars 25. 1. I have been using vitamin E oil on her face. You can purchase vitamin E in liquid or capsule form. A 2002 study performed on rabbit ears at Northwestern University Medical School in Chicago showed a significant improvement in dermal collagen organization following the use of Mederma 2. Please check with the appropriate physician regarding health questions and concerns. Mederma is a topical formulation which is very simple to use. Upon the prescribed use of this gel, the color, visibility and texture of your scars will improve tremendously. I like your combination efforts. Mederma Skin Care for Scars is a greaseless, invisible topical gel 2. // Leaf Group Lifestyle, How to Rub Vitamin E on the Scalp to Promote Hair Growth. In this Mederma vs. Neosporin match-up, we will compare and contrast two popular scar products that can be used to minimize the appearance of scars. I am very opposed to Vitamin E because, chemically, Vitamin E breaks the SH bonds. So in conclusion, there's no evidence it works, but no real evidence it does not. Vaseline is cheaper and shows to be at least just as good at hydration (which appears to be what makes scars improve). September 11, 2018. Is this too early to start treating the scar? Answered by Dr. Richard Tholen: Sure. J Clin Aesthet Dermatol. Copyright © 2021 Leaf Group Ltd., all rights reserved. 9. Owji N, Khademi B, Khalili MR. The information contained on this site is for informational purposes only, and should not be used as a substitute for the advice of a professional health care provider. The information on RealSelf is intended for educational purposes only.